Get Full Essay Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues. It suggests that soldiers fighting in the World War were brave and courageous as he refers to them as lions. In comparison their leaders, the generals were mindless and stupid like donkeys. By holding these characteristics many believe generals exposed hundreds of thousands of British soldiers to their death.
Hire Writer The soldiers had to face huge, heavy weapons being fired at them.
|Lions led by donkeys – Assignment Example||In the First World War, more men died than in any other war before.|
This was also experienced by the Germans off the same guns which were being fired from the British. This is shown in source A2. There were all types of new weapons which were being used from both sides. Machine guns had been introduced.
These guns were capable of causing mutilating injuries.
The soldiers had to deal with this night and day with very little in the way of protection such as body armour which would have been capable of stopping a bullet.
They were expected to carry with them all of there equipment and were to fight for their lives with bayonets. However they were bombarded with heavy machinegun fire as soon as there heads were out of the trenches.
It would be highly unlikely for any soldier to make it to the German trenches under these circumstances. This again shows how brave these men really were in the war. This is more evidence to say that the generals were incompetent and were unable to fight a war with these new technical advances.
Sir Douglas Haig was a very experienced soldier and had commander-in-Chief for three years. He had Lions led by donkeys essay example in the Sudan and the then the Boer war in However these wars were very one sided as the enemy were poorly equipped.
He was appointed commander-in-chief of the British forces on the Western Front in and was then promoted to the rank of Field Marshal on 3rd January However Haig could have got this position sourly because he was married to one of the Queens, ladies in waiting. At the end of the war he was made an Earl and awarded i??
Whilst Haig was in charge of the British army approximately half a million soldiers died. However it has to be kept in mind that Haig got Britain through the war to a victory. This shows that they must have a reason to have such faith in his ability.
This source also suggests that Haig may have been appointed not on merit of his skills but because of the Kings fondness of him. This would reinforce the opinion that the generals were donkeys as the soldiers were being led by men who were not fully qualified. This shows that he is set in his ways and will sacrifices any amount of soldiers to save his country illustrating that Haig was extremely narrow minded and once again contradicting the reason for him to have been placed in control of the army.
Haig believed that along with Parliament that Britain must believe that the soldiers are doing well and that there is a strong chances that they are going to win the war. This tells us that the generals knew that is was a war in which they were fighting both the Germans and the British public for the reason that once the public knew about it they would demand the surrender of Britain, therefore loosing the war.
This shows that the generals were fighting to win the war and were going about it in the only way they believed fit.
Source B5 is one of many news reports from British newspapers which were published mainly to maintain moral on the home front.
This is more than likely to be propaganda as it was sent to the news of the world from the British headquarters The thinking behind it was that keeping good news flowing from the frontline would encourage the nation to put as much work into the war effort as possible.
In the report there it is saying about an attack lunched in the north of River Somme which was supported by the French. This attack was to reduce pressure off Verdun.
The idea of the attack was to spread the German troops too thinly between Verdun and Somme. This attack was successful in reducing pressure from the French however not much land was gained despite the immensely high numbers of casualties.
One estimate was that there were 57, deaths. Within the first hour alone on the first day of the Somme 21, soldiers were killed!
This suggests that source B5 does not give a true understanding of what was happening in reality. It gives the impression that the generals are doing an excellent job as the soldiers are defeating the Germans. However as we have already discovered the article was incorrect and there were many lives lost in the Battle of the Somme and a very small amount of land was retreated from there deaths, so even though the Somme did reduce the pressure in Verdun the generals sent thousands to their death to do this.
Poems are great insights to what the soldiers were facing during the war as they are written from how they are feeling at this time, this means they are extremely helpful to find out more about how the men felt about the war and being apart of it.Some people hold the view that the British soldiers of the First World War were ‘Lions lead by donkeys’.
The accusations are that the generals controlled the army with poor leadership with no remorse to the high numbers of deaths and casualties. We will write a custom essay sample on Lions Led by Donkeys specifically for you. for only. Lions Led By Donkeys Ever since the end of WW1 in which was won by the British allies against the Germans it, has been hugely debated whether the famous .
Lions Led By Donkeys Ever since the end of WW1 in which was won by the British allies against the Germans it, has been hugely debated whether the famous interpretation 'Lions Led by Donkeys' is correct.
I am going to look at various peoples interpretations of this statement to . Home Essays Lions Led by Donkeys How accurate is the statement ‘Lions led by donkeys’ in relation to British Soldiers and Generals of the First World War?
In the First World War, more men died than in . The question “were the British soldiers ‘Lions led by Donkeys?'” has been an ongoing debate since the end of the war.
A war which is dominated by images of bloody battles such as the Somme and Passchendaele – futile frontal attacks against the machine guns. History-Lions Led by Donkeys Essay Sample. Written by Alan Clark a politician in the s this quotation describes the leadership of the British Military and their strategies used in the Great War.